Are you sure the site doesn't show in the serps. Have you checked the domain at Mcdar? If it doesn't show up then the site could be sandboxed for that term.

There is a misunderstanding that being ranked high for allinanchor and/or allintitle means that you will rank high in the serps. Realize that even if your allinanchor/title ranking is high, if your overall inbound link count is very low in comparison to your competition, you could be ranked hundreds of positions lower in the serps.

I think domain age has much to do with rankings too.